Anthony hosted my family at his Farmingdale location for my sons communion. It was a 10 out of 10 experience. From meeting with anthony about the menu, to the day of running smoothly, the food was delicious, the service was outstanding, and the space was private and perfect for our event. I cant thank Anthony and his staff enough. I highly recommend this venue for a private event!

-Nicki G.

My friend and I needed a girls' night out. We made a walk-in reservation at a previous restaurant but there was a 1.5-hour wait. We decided to drive around the island. By chance, we were passing Anthony’s kitchen and cocktail and we decided to stop in a check it out. From the moment we called, customer service was perfection and accurate.

-Tameka M.

The food is always on point ! They have amazing new seafood specials just in time for lent! Tia place never disappoints !

-Lauren G.

This place blew me away. I’ll be honest, when my wife told he where we were going i had very little expectations. From the service to the food, everything was terrific. We ordered basically the entire menu (big group) and everything was delicious. Both the grilled and fried calamari were great. The veal entree was outstanding. All the pastas were prepared perfectly. We will without a doubt be going back.

-Brendan P.

My wife and I went at the urging of a friend for a date night. Hard to come by those these days. Boy, are we glad we chose to spend it at Anthony’s. The ambiance is perfect. Warm, quiet, friendly(we were there at 6:45pm last night, Friday).

-Sean H.

Overall had a great experience. Stuffed veal chop was amazing, mussels, clams and pastas were all very good also. Drinks took a long time to get to table but when we were sitting at bar waiting for table the drinks were coming fast. Not sure what happened.

-Paul E.

Anthony's was amazing. Great place, Anthony is very personable with everyone. Great service, delicious food. We had 5 different appetizers, everyone had main courses from stuffed veal, to the pork chop Sinatra, Grandma's veal, and lamb chops and every dish was fresh, great spread Anthony put out. Our waiter John was great and the bartender was on point with the espresso martinis. Great place we will be back.

-Chad P.

Great local Italian-American restaurant with delicious and freshly prepared food favorites and genuinely friendly customer service. They have parking in the rear and there is a nearby shopping plaza with ample parking that I assume one may use- check with the restaurant upon arrival. Louis, greeted us with a big friendly smile and he immediately seated us at the table of our choice. Our host and server Dina was spectacular! She was very cheerful, obliging and happy to help and provided us with world-class service. They offer a balanced menu and everything that moves around you looks and smells so good! The restaurant is very cozy with the correct amount of lighting, music genres and volume level. The bathroom is kept clean.

-Chuck W.

Grabbed dinner with my friend on Friday night as we wanted to check out this new place for the first time. We were fortunate to get a parking spot behind the restaurant (But only because someone just so happened to be pulling out as we arrived). The restaurant was elegant, quaint, and cozy. We ordered the mama’s meatballs, pasta nonna rigatoni, and a Prosecco. The Prosecco was slightly flat, but besides for that everything was delicious. The food came out at the speed of light and the service was delightful. We would return here again, especially to try the dessert which we didn’t have the room for as we were so stuffed after our meal!